Joe's Pasty Shop Reviews, Ratings & Menu | 123 Randall Ave, Rhinelander

General Info

Nestled just off 123 Randall Ave in Rhinelander, Wisconsin, Joe's Pasty Shop is a cozy takeout spot that has quickly become a favorite for locals and visitors alike. Tucked behind the main building with access through the parking lot on Courtney Street, this little gem makes every visit feel like a treat. From the moment you arrive, the friendly staff greets you with a warm smile, making the pick-up experience both smooth and inviting.

The star of the menu here is undoubtedly the Apple pasty. Each one is baked to perfection, with a flaky, golden crust that holds a tender, sweet apple filling inside. The flavor strikes a perfect balance between natural fruitiness and a touch of cinnamon, offering that comforting homemade feel in every bite. Even those new to pasties will find themselves impressed by the quality and care in each order. For those seeking variety, Joe’s Pasty Shop also provides vegetarian-friendly options, ensuring there’s something for everyone.

Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch on the go or planning a small gathering, the restaurant’s delivery service makes enjoying these treats effortless. Many regulars appreciate the ability to schedule orders in advance or simply walk in and grab a fresh pasty to enjoy immediately. Reservations are accepted, which comes in handy during busier times, especially when word-of-mouth reviews bring in new fans eager to try the signature dishes.

One of the highlights of Joe’s Pasty Shop is the combination of convenience and quality. Paying is simple with debit cards accepted, and the onsite services ensure you don’t have to wait long for your order. The casual, approachable atmosphere encourages people to pop in, whether they’re stopping by daily or exploring Rhinelander for the first time.

From the careful attention to each pasty to the thoughtful service, the location feels both welcoming and reliable. Customers often mention in their reviews how Joe’s Pasty Shop manages to maintain a consistent quality that makes it easy to keep coming back. The aroma of freshly baked apple pasties wafting from the kitchen adds to the experience, making each visit a little sensory delight. For anyone seeking a tasty, approachable takeout experience in Rhinelander, this spot delivers a satisfying and memorable menu that keeps patrons returning.

What customers say?

“ I am a Pasty snob like most Pasty lovers. I have enjoyed many in Cornwall England, the home of the Pasty. We make them at home and attend "Pasty Parties", I like a good curry Pasty and I like a traditional with New Mexico green chili. We took a trip to Northern Wisconsin and discovered this gem. Cute little Shop and a lovely lady working there. We could smell them as soon as we opened our car doors. To our horror we discovered they don't sell them ready to eat. They make them and freeze them, you take them home and finish cooking them in your oven. We bought six, 1 Cornish, 1 Traditional, 1 Ruben, 1 Bacon Cheeseburger and 1 Southwest, 1 Greek! (Wow!!) The Ruben blew my mind, seemed a sacrilege and that may have made it taste when better. Long story longer, every Pasty I ate became the best Pasty I ever ate! We cut them at the table and shared. Better than in Cornwall and better than we can make at home. Great crust, quality ingredients, minced steak, tender veggies... Soooo good! We ate until we hurt and don't regret it. I don't know who Joe is but good job mate! Rhinelander is almost 2 hours away but I see myself making the trip all too happily! ”

- Carl O'Neil -

“ I just recently placed an order for shipment and received it yesterday and I have to say the process was very easy and the pasties are so delicious. I was lucky to get in one more order before their spring break, I'm so excited. I love these pasties and have been enjoying them for years. Thank you for continuing to make them:) ”

- Jenny Buckingham -

“ We picked up 3 pasties for dinner. bacon cheeseburger, pizza, and Cornish. All were delicious! On par with Randall's Pasties in the UP!! Beautiful/flavorful dough which is key to a good pasty! We'll be back soon for more! Very well organized with our order when we came to pick them up!! They come frozen so you do have to take and bake yourself, but very easy and we'll worth the effort!! They give you easy to follow instructions on how to bake!! Can't go wrong!! ”

- MAK1975 (MAK1975) -